The Pros And Cons Of Artificial Sweeteners

Managing diabetes is a near-constant effort, one that requires balance and monitoring everything you eat. Rarely is it possible to consume anything without first considering how it will affect your numbers. There is a common misconception that all of this regulation includes eliminating sugar from your diet altogether, but that’s not necessary. What is necessary? Moderation… and knowing which sugars are best for you. Which begs the question: what about artificial sweeteners?

Well, we’ve got you covered. Here’s the lowdown on the “goods” and “bads” of artificial sweeteners.

The Good

They Satisfy Your Cravings

You can use these low-calorie sugars as substitutes in your favorite snacks and beverages. Opting for artificial sweeteners allows you to reduce carbohydrates, which means satisfying your cravings while maintaining control over your glucose levels.

Gummy Bears

Less Is More

A little goes a long way. Most artificial sweeteners are around 100 times sweeter than regular sugar, so you only need a small amount to kick the craving.

They’ve Received the FDA’s “GRAS” Stamp of Approval

The FDA has approved 6 artificial sweeteners and deemed them generally accepted as safe (GRAS), which means multiple studies have been performed to verify they’re safe for consumption in moderation.

So, what’s available?

Article continues below

Our Featured Programs

See how we’re making a difference for People, Pets, and the Planet and how you can get involved!

Acesulfame-potassium (AKA, Ace K)

Typically combined with an additional low-calorie sweeter to provide a taste more similar to sucrose.

Uses: Baking, carbonated drinks

Brand names: Sweet One®, Sunett®


While this artificial sweetener was linked to bladder cancer in the 1970s, the FDA later dismissed those claims.

Uses: Canning, cooking, baking, tabletop sweetener

Brand names: Sweet ‘N Low®, Sugar Twin®

How you can spot it: Look for the pink packet.



Stevia comes from the stevia plant. Not all stevia products have received GRAS status.

Uses: Tabletop sweetener

Brand names: Stevia®, Truvia®, PureVia®6.

How you can spot it: Look for the green packet.


While studies show that aspartame is safe to drink, the warning label suggests that people with certain diseases should avoid it.

Uses: Foods, beverages, tabletop sweetener

Brand names: Equal®, Nutrasweet®

How you can spot it: Look for the blue packet.


Sucralose is made from sucrose and involves multiple steps which alter the molecular structure of its atoms.

Uses: Baking, cooking, tabletop sweetener

Brand names: Splenda®

How you can spot it: Look for the yellow packet.


This product, which is not available in stores, is nearly 8,000 times sweeter than sugar, making it ideal for large food and beverage manufacturers.

Uses: Additive for foods and beverages

The Bad

Confusing Labeling

Artificial sweeteners frequently boast enticing buzzwords like “natural”. However, these terms are misleading because they don’t account for the fact that they are often processed and refined.


Speaking of Misleading Labels…

Make sure you look beyond marketing ploys that tout items as “Sugar Free!” or “Reduced Sugar!” These products often contain more calories and carbohydrates than their original counterparts.

What About Those Cancer Scares Mentioned Earlier?

While artificial sweeteners have been under scrutiny for decades, health agencies, including the National Cancer Institute, have revealed that scientific evidence has not shown a link between artificial sweeteners and cancer and other health problems. However, the FDA, in conjunction with approving the aforementioned 6 artificial sweeteners, has also established an acceptable daily intake (ADI). These ADIs depict a number that is approximately 100 times less than the smallest amount that might cause health concerns.

What does this tell us?

Pay attention to nutrition labels and consume artificial sweeteners in moderation. You can get your sweet fix, but it’s crucial that you know what you’re consuming.

Support Research

Fund Diabetes research and care at The Diabetes Site for free!